Fans database sets forth the scientific basis for concerns regarding the safety and effectiveness of ingesting fluorides. For more than half a century, water fluoridation has helped improve the quality of life in the u. Pew childrens dental campaign fluoridation is the single most effective public health measure to prevent tooth decay and improve oral. Water fluoridation was once heralded as one of the best public health. Top 10 reasons to oppose water fluoridation oral answers. This report offers comments on the listed 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation by dr connett. Fluoridation is the single most important commitment a community can make to the oral health of its children and to future generations. Food and drug administration fda classifies fluoride as a drug when used to prevent or mitigate disease fda 2000. Read his 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation here and see a more detailed bio here. Community water fluoridation is a public health effort that benefits millions of americans. No disease has ever been linked to a fluoride deficiency.
The centers for disease control and prevention cdc has proclaimed community water fluoridation one of 10 great public health achievements of the 20th century. The document was refined in 2004 and published in medical veritas. Since water fluoridation is a form of medication, it will be impossible to control the amount of water consumed by each individual because different people consume different amounts of water daily. Refute of paul connetts 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation.
Fluoride is a natural element found in rocks and soil everywhere, in fresh water, and in ocean water. Paul connett now professor emeritus of chemistry st. The fluoride action network has a list of 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation. Water fluoridation is one example of the government trying to do things for the people. Most developed countries, including japan and 97% of the western european population, do not consume fluoridated water. Arguments against water fluoridation are just folklore. I am quite convinced that water fluoridation, in a nottoodistant future, will be consigned to medical history. The controversy over community water fluoridation pdxscholar. Anita shattuck is working to oppose the fluoridation of water supplies in escondido, california.
Lawrence university in canton, ny offers 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation as listed below and the statements are slightly edited. Fluoride in drinking water 50 reasons to opppose fluoridation why over 3500 medicaldentalscientific professionals are opposed to artificial water fluoridation and have signed a petition to stop fluoridation. Fluoride is already present in all water sources, even the oceans. As another person interested in this debate i ask to offer several comments on your top 10 reasons to support water fluoridation. Other aspects of water fluoridation also described. The 50 reasons offered in this article for opposing fluoridation are based on a thorough. Response to a list of 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation, compiled by dr connett responses by tw cutress section 1. The 50 reasons were first compiled by paul connett and presented in person to the irish fluoridation forum in october 2000. Analysis of its effects and reasons behind the arguments. Humans can have perfectly good teeth without fluoride. Most western european countries are not fluoridated and have experienced the same decline in dental decay as the us see data from world health organization on levels of tooth decay in europe, us, new zealand. Response to a list of 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation compiled by dr connett. If anything, the teeth in unfluoridated kingston were slightly better kumar and.
It is a persons responsibility to learn about the pros and cons of fluoride and then decide if they want to utilize fluoride in their oral health routine. Fluoride is the only chemical added to water for the purpose of medical treatment. Response to a list of 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation. Fluoride action network 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation. This page formatting and material kindly donated by fluoride free lethbridge. Fifty reasons to oppose fluoridation request pdf researchgate. A rebuttal of fans 50 reasons years ago, the fluoride action network fan created a web page called 50 reasons to oppose water fluoridation that its leader, paul connett, widely circulates. Cdha has not developed a fluoride position relating to oral health promotion. As a matter of basic logic, adding fluoride to water for the sole purpose of preventing tooth decay a nonwater borne disease is a form of. Canadian directory of fluoridation opponentsopposition.
Single most effective public health measure to prevent tooth decay. Asns s fi 2 fluoridation is the practice of adding a fluoride compound to the public drinking water supply ostensibly for the purpose of fighting tooth decay. By by paul connett, phd in europe, only ireland 73%, poland 1%, serbia 3%, spain 11%, and the u. Wigton aspatria maryport workington whitehaven egremont ravenglass m6 motorway fluoridation in cumbria. For conciseness, this response to 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation is. Cutress, a member of the medical research council in new zealand, examined these 50 reasons and drafted this analysis. The centers for disease control and prevention cdc has proclaimed community water fluoridation one of 10 great public health achievements of. The campaign against the fluoridation of water is communicating a form of modern folklore. Instead of forcing water fluoridation on the public, we need a safe water bill that ensures that no chemical can be added to the water with the intention of medicating people unless it has been. Public opinion polls have consistently shown 70% or more of the adult us population supports fluoridation.
Controversies in sciencewater fluoridationa critique of. Paul connett is a prominent water fluoridation critic, executive director of the binghamton, new york based fluoride action network fan, one of the largest organizations opposing water fluoridation worldwide. Request pdf fifty reasons to oppose fluoridation 1 fluoride is not an essential nutrient. General comments this report offers comments on the listed 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation by dr connett. Water fluoridation natures way to prevent tooth decay. For further information contact citizens for safe drinking water 8007283833, greenjeff at. Links to key documents on community water fluoridation. Cdha advocates clean and toxinfree sources of fluoride for use in. The water fluoridation controversy arises from political, moral, ethical, economic, and health considerations regarding the fluoridation of public water supplies for deprived groups in both maturing and matured countries, international and national agencies and dental associations across the world support the safety and effectiveness of water fluoridation. Subscribe to fluoride action networks fan free enewsletter and help support fans work by giving a donation today via our secure online payment system. In 50 reasons to oppose fluoridation, 63 paul connett, phd, professor of chemistry at st. Scribd is the worlds largest social reading and publishing site. We have categorized these reasons along the lines of ethicschoice, need, effectiveness, safety, equity, efficiencycost, and scienti fic evidence, each of which is enough to generate serious questions. Lawrence university new york, states that the supposedly safe fluoride levels in our water may pose a particular danger for any of the millions of people who suffer from thyroid disorders.
Other fluoridation battles are currently taking place in santa monica, ca and in the state of ohio. Learn why fluoridation is a bad medical practice that is unnecessary and ineffective. Questions and answers this more detailed technical resource has been prepared by nsw health to assist communities and professionals understand the process of fluoridation, the evidence supporting the benefits of fluoridationand the evidence cited to support claims made about harms associated with fluoridation. In fact, waters in and around the united states have natural luoride levels that range from 0. Top 10 reasons to support water fluoridation oral answers. Connett has been invited by environmental organizations opposing fluoridation to come and lecture on the subject in fluoridating countries such as canada, israel, australia and new zealand. This thesis is brought to you for free and open access. Some of the reasons to oppose water fluoridation include concerns about its lack of safety and its impact on human health and the environment.
1344 1186 529 753 1316 685 1155 39 136 772 38 530 1033 1412 1032 1493 738 1027 1400 1217 1403 1297 458 1220 1274 684 1292 1479 864 706 246 173 750 869 1069 1385 1356 1303 287 493 199 1480 696 859 2